What the review team checks when you submit a file
What a reviewer looks at, what they never look at, what each decision means and how long the process usually takes.
12 October 2026 · 6 minute read · The Trackly team
Review in Trackly applies only to files you choose to submit. Your everyday logging is yours and appears immediately, with nobody approving it. Review exists so that an imported file or a progress photo can be marked as checked rather than simply self reported, and so that a file nobody can read does not sit in your history pretending to be data.
This article says exactly what the check involves, because a review process that is vague about its own criteria is not much use to the person submitting.
What a reviewer looks at
- Whether the file opens and can be read at all.
- Whether there is a single header row and one record per row.
- Whether the columns match what Trackly expects for that kind of record.
- Whether dates are in a single unambiguous format and fall in a plausible range.
- Whether numeric columns contain numbers, in one unit, with the unit stated.
- Whether rows duplicate entries already in your account.
- For an image, whether it is a progress photo of the kind the page asks for, and whether it is legible.
That is the whole list. It is a check on the quality of the file, not on you.
What a reviewer never does
- Judge your training, your figures or your rate of progress.
- Comment on your body, your weight or a photograph beyond whether it is usable.
- Change the figures in your file.
- Give training, nutrition or medical advice.
- Read records in your account that are unrelated to the submission.
A reviewer sees the submitted file, the account it came from and the note you attached. Decisions and comments are stored with the upload record, so you can always see who decided what and when.
The four decisions
Every submission ends in one of four states, and each one carries a written comment.
- Under review: the file has been opened and is being checked. No action from you.
- Approved: the file is readable and consistent, and the record is marked as checked.
- Needs changes: something specific is wrong and can be fixed. The record stays open and you can upload a corrected file against the same submission.
- Rejected: the file cannot be used, for example because it is unreadable, empty, the wrong kind of file, or appears to belong to someone else. The reason explains why.
Needs changes is by far the most common outcome for a first upload, and it is not a mark against you. It usually means a date column was ambiguous or a numeric column had units in the cells.
How long it takes
Submissions are reviewed in the order they arrive. You get an email when your file reaches the queue and another when a decision is recorded. If you have not heard anything and the status has not moved, use the contact form with the file name and the date you submitted it.
Trackly does not publish a turnaround time it cannot guarantee, so there is no promised figure here. The status in the application is always current.
How to make a review go quickly
- Read the upload preview before submitting and fix anything it flags.
- Write a note saying where the file came from, what the rows are and which units you used.
- Submit one kind of record per file rather than mixing workouts and measurements.
- Use ISO dates, which removes the single most common query.
- If you are resubmitting, say what you changed.
If you disagree with a decision
Reply through the contact form with the upload reference and the reviewer comment you received. A different reviewer will look at it. Decisions are recorded with the account that made them, so it is straightforward to work out what happened.
Approval means a file was readable and internally consistent. It is not a verification that the figures in it are true, and it is not an endorsement of your training. Nothing in the review process is medical or coaching advice.
Record it while it is fresh
Trackly keeps the detail so a session from March can be compared with the same session in September.